Daily news

Trump Still Wants to Buy Bitcoin for US Reserve, but Legal Authority Is Missing, Ex-Adviser Witt Says

Former White House crypto council director Patrick Witt says President Trump is still interested in buying bitcoin for the U.S. Strategic Bitcoin Reserve, but outright open-market purchases are "of questionable legality" because Congress controls spending. No purchase or budget-neutral plan has been announced, and making the reserve permanent looks harder after the midterms.

MyTraderBot DeskPublished: 9 min readخواندن به فارسی
Share
U.S. Treasury Building in Washington, D.C., with the Albert Gallatin statue in front, and MyTraderBot branding in the corner
U.S. Treasury Building, Washington. Photo: Tony Webster / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0; modified.
Table of Contents

President Donald Trump is still interested in buying bitcoin for the U.S. Strategic Bitcoin Reserve, but the government has no clear legal authority to make outright open-market purchases, according to Patrick Witt, the former executive director of the White House crypto council. His comments, made on the What Bitcoin Did podcast, are the most detailed public account so far of why the reserve created in March 2025 has not added a single purchased coin.

The episode, "Inside the White House's Plan to Buy Bitcoin," was published on November 9, 2026 at 17:05 UTC (20:35 Tehran time), according to the podcast's listing. The show notes say the conversation was recorded before the November 3 U.S. midterm elections. Coverage by CoinMarketCap Academy and Bitcoin.com News followed on November 11–12. This report is based on the published transcript excerpts, the text of the executive order on the White House website, and those two independent write-ups.

What Patrick Witt said

Witt, who led the President's Council of Advisers for Digital Assets (widely known as the White House Crypto Council) until he left for the private sector in October, was direct about the president's appetite. "I can tell you the president's interested in it. I can tell you that there's been a lot of discussion about how we might be able to do that," he said.

The obstacle, in his telling, is authority rather than intent. "It's of questionable legality whether or not there could be outright open market purchases," Witt said, pointing to the fact that Congress, not the White House, controls federal spending.

He also explained why the administration held back. According to CoinMarketCap's account of the interview, Witt said: "We didn't necessarily want to do something that then had a boomerang effect and led Congress to actually put a rider in the NDAA that says you cannot do this." He added: "We're trying to get to the place where it is permitted and where the authority is granted, so we didn't want to do anything that jeopardized that."

A note on the NDAA "rider"

Some early summaries of the interview reported that Congress has already inserted a provision into the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) banning federal bitcoin purchases. The quote published by CoinMarketCap does not say that. In that wording, Witt describes a rider as a risk the administration wanted to avoid by not acting without clear authority, not as an existing law. MyTraderBot has not found a primary legislative text confirming such a ban, so readers should treat claims of an enacted NDAA prohibition as unverified.

What the 2025 executive order actually requires

The reserve rests on the executive order "Establishment of the Strategic Bitcoin Reserve and United States Digital Asset Stockpile," signed on March 6, 2025. Its key provisions, as published by the White House, are:

  • Funding source: the reserve is capitalized with bitcoin held by the Treasury that was "finally forfeited" in criminal or civil asset forfeiture proceedings or received in satisfaction of civil money penalties.

  • No sales: bitcoin deposited into the reserve "shall not be sold" and is to be maintained as a reserve asset of the United States.

  • Budget-neutral acquisition only: the Treasury and Commerce secretaries "shall develop strategies for acquiring additional Government BTC provided that such strategies are budget neutral and do not impose incremental costs on United States taxpayers."

  • Separate stockpile for other tokens: non-bitcoin assets go to a "Digital Asset Stockpile," and the government may not acquire more of them except through forfeiture or penalties "without further executive or legislative action."

  • Accounting and review deadlines: agencies had 30 days to report their holdings, and Treasury had 60 days to deliver an evaluation of the legal and investment considerations, "including ... the need for any legislation."

  • Limits: the order must be implemented "consistent with applicable law and subject to the availability of appropriations."

That last clause is central to Witt's argument. An executive order can direct agencies, but it cannot appropriate money. Buying bitcoin on the open market with new federal funds would normally require congressional approval, which is why the order asks only for "budget neutral" strategies. More than 18 months after the order, no such strategy has been made public and no purchase has been announced.

The unfinished audit and custody problems

Witt also described what the council found when it tried to account for the government's existing coins. According to the episode description, the audit of government-held bitcoin remains unfinished. In the transcript, he called custody practices across agencies "unbelievable," saying: "sometimes cold wallets, you know, kept in drawers, sometimes with a third party custodian. In certain cases, you know, a professional custodian."

He referred to an alleged theft involving a U.S. Marshals Service contractor, describing it as an example of "totally unacceptable custody practices." Witt also said the council "found evidence of almost like punitive" efforts to "dump the asset on the market." These are his characterizations; the transcript excerpts do not identify specific agencies, dates or amounts, and MyTraderBot could not independently verify them.

Why making the reserve permanent looks harder

Because the reserve exists only by executive order, a future president could amend or revoke it. Witt noted that repealing a predecessor's orders is "one of the first things they do."

Asked whether the reserve could be written into law before the end of Trump's term, he said: "It's going to be hard. It's going to be really hard." Parts might ride on a larger bill, he suggested, but "passing a standalone bill around that is going to be incredibly difficult with a divided Congress."

The political backdrop has shifted since the recording. CoinMarketCap and Bitcoin.com News both report that Democrats won control of both chambers in the November 3 midterms. Witt said crypto "really became a political issue" and that he would "struggle to imagine Democrats passing something" seen as a Republican priority. MyTraderBot recently covered how the leadership change in the House affects crypto legislation in its report on Tom Emmer's new role and the CLARITY Act.

Witt's own tenure reflects that friction. He said he was initially asked to stay "six to eight weeks" to help pass the CLARITY market-structure bill, but stayed more than a year; the bill ultimately failed on the Senate floor. He also said he does not expect the White House's central coordinating role on crypto to continue.

Timeline

  • March 6, 2025: Trump signs the executive order creating the Strategic Bitcoin Reserve and the Digital Asset Stockpile.

  • September 2026: the CLARITY Act fails to advance in the Senate, according to CoinMarketCap.

  • October 2026: Witt leaves the White House crypto council for the private sector.

  • Before November 3, 2026: the podcast interview is recorded.

  • November 3, 2026: U.S. midterm elections.

  • November 9, 2026, 20:35 Tehran time: the episode is published.

  • November 11–12, 2026: crypto media report Witt's comments.

What it means for the bitcoin market

For traders, the main takeaway is that a U.S. government bid for bitcoin is not imminent. Witt's remarks confirm interest at the top, but they also describe a legal barrier that the administration chose not to test. A government buying program, if it ever comes, would likely need either new legislation or a budget-neutral mechanism that survives legal scrutiny.

The policy news also lands in a weak market. CoinGecko showed bitcoin at about $73,474 at 09:13 Tehran time on November 12, 2026 (05:43 UTC). Prices have been under pressure from hotter U.S. inflation data and spot ETF outflows, as covered in MyTraderBot's report on bitcoin falling below $74,000 after the October CPI. Institutional demand is also being tested by MSCI's decision to remove Strategy and Metaplanet from its indexes.

This is news, not a trading signal. Policy headlines can move prices briefly in either direction, and reserve-related rumors have triggered sharp swings before. Readers should be cautious of social media posts claiming that federal purchases have started; no official source has announced any.

Key terms explained

  • Strategic Bitcoin Reserve (SBR): a set of Treasury-controlled accounts holding bitcoin forfeited to the U.S. government, created by executive order and barred from being sold.

  • Budget neutral: a way of acquiring assets that does not add to federal spending or cost taxpayers, for example by swapping or revaluing existing assets.

  • Open-market purchase: buying bitcoin at market prices from exchanges or OTC desks using government funds.

  • NDAA rider: a provision attached to the annual National Defense Authorization Act, a must-pass bill often used to carry unrelated policy.

  • Asset forfeiture: the legal process through which the government takes ownership of property linked to crimes.

What to watch next

  • Any Treasury publication of the budget-neutral acquisition strategies or the legal evaluation required by the 2025 order.

  • Whether the final text of the next NDAA or any spending bill contains language on federal digital asset purchases.

  • Results of the government bitcoin audit Witt described as unfinished, and any change in custody arrangements.

  • The new Congress's stance on crypto bills, including market-structure legislation, when it convenes in January.

  • Whether the White House keeps a dedicated crypto coordinating office after Witt's departure.

Frequently asked questions

Has the U.S. government bought any bitcoin for the reserve?

No purchase has been announced. The reserve is funded with forfeited bitcoin, and no budget-neutral acquisition strategy has been published.

Is there a law banning the government from buying bitcoin?

MyTraderBot has not found one. Witt's quoted remarks describe an NDAA rider as a possible congressional reaction the administration wanted to avoid, not as enacted law.

Can a future president cancel the reserve?

Yes. Because it rests on an executive order, a future president could amend or revoke it, unless Congress writes it into law.

Sources

  • What Bitcoin Did, "Inside the White House's Plan to Buy Bitcoin | Patrick Witt," published November 9, 2026: whatbitcoindid.com; transcript excerpts via Podscan

  • The White House, executive order "Establishment of the Strategic Bitcoin Reserve and United States Digital Asset Stockpile," March 6, 2025: whitehouse.gov

  • CoinMarketCap Academy, "Trump Wants to Buy Bitcoin for US Reserve, Former Adviser Says," November 2026: coinmarketcap.com

  • Bitcoin.com News, "Trump Still Wants to Buy Bitcoin but a Legal Wall Stands in the Way: Witt," November 2026: news.bitcoin.com

  • Price: CoinGecko, BTC/USD, observed November 12, 2026, 09:13 Tehran time.

Coins mentioned
  • BTCBitcoin
Share

See the signals and their results

Browse publicly logged signals and how they performed, or create a free account to follow them.

Strategic Bitcoin Reserve: Why the US Hasn't Bought Bitcoin